Album Review
I first became aware of “Throw Your Arms Around Me” back in the '90s because Pearl Jam covered it in concert quite a few times. That was my introduction to the song, and it remains the first thing I think of when I hear the name Hunters & Collectors. Eddie Vedder's voice suited it well, but hearing Mark Seymour sing it gives the song a different feeling. There is a roughness in his voice that makes the affection sound a little more desperate.
Human Frailty has plenty to offer beyond that one song. “Say Goodbye” opens the album with a strong bass line and a performance that gets your attention right away. Seymour sounds frustrated and hurt, and the band gives him something solid to lean into. I like the way the horns fit into these songs. They add character without making the music feel too crowded.
“Throw Your Arms Around Me” is still my favorite here. It has one of those melodies that stays with you long after the song ends, and it doesn't need much dressing up to work. The Hunters & Collectors version has its own warmth and urgency. Even with my attachment to Pearl Jam's performances, the original belongs on any list of this band's best songs.
“Everything's on Fire” is another highlight, bringing together a memorable chorus and the restless energy that runs through the album. “Relief” slows things down a little, while “The Finger” and “Dog” give the record some welcome grit. “This Morning” closes things with a more reflective mood, and I appreciate that the band lets the album finish that way.
Not every song connects with me as strongly as the best ones. A few arrangements show their age, and Seymour's forceful delivery can wear a little thin. Still, the bass, drums and brass give the music enough personality to keep it interesting. This is a band with a sound of its own.
Human Frailty is a very good album that deserves attention beyond “Throw Your Arms Around Me.” Pearl Jam gave me a reason to notice that song back in the '90s, but Hunters & Collectors give me plenty of reasons to listen to the rest of the record.
