Albums: Ranked from Good to Best

Some people only know Nada Surf from their one mainstream hit, 1996's "Popular." To be honest, "Popular" isn't even close to being one of their best songs. It's a shame that they are mostly known for that one song — a one-hit wonder, so to speak — when they have crafted great album after great album. A one-hit wonder they are not. Here is the ranking of their albums.

5.  Never Not Together (2020)

Optimistic without being naive. The band stretches out a little more here, especially on "Just Wait" and "Something I Should Do," while retaining the warmth and melodic character that define their best work.

4.  Moon Mirror (2024)

A graceful late-career record rather than an attempt to reinvent the band. The melodies are familiar, but Matthew Caws' reflections on time, relationships and getting older give the album considerable emotional weight.

3.  Lucky (2008)

"Lucky" just might be their most upbeat album to date. This disc is full of highlights, one after the next. Nada Surf just might still be the biggest secret in the music world, always full of catchy, uplifting tunes. This might not be their best effort, but it's safe to say most bands would love to have an album like this be their shining moment.

2.  The Weight Is a Gift (2005)

What do ya know, another well-crafted pop album packed full of emotional, intelligent power pop. One of the few bands that refuses to write a bad album. They release one great disc after another. Arguably, this could be their greatest album. I went back and forth, putting it at #1 and then back to #2. I can't quite put my finger on why this album didn't end up on the top of the list. Nonetheless, it deserves to be there. Maybe there should have been a tie.

1.  Let Go (2003)

"Let Go's" biggest strength is its melodies. Every song has a satisfying, catchy melody. This album is near pop perfection, a true gem. The musicianship, as always, is excellent. Some might call this album a pop masterpiece. I wouldn't argue against it. I don't think it's logical to challenge their brilliance. Let's just hope they have a few more albums left in them.